NABJ Called Out Stephen A. Smith. He Went to Fox News

August 19, 2026

ESPN commentator Stephen A. Smith is embroiled in a public dispute with the National Association of Black Journalists after receiving their "Thumbs Down Award" for allegedly making disparaging comments about prominent Black women in politics, sports, and media. Smith vehemently denies the accusations, claiming he simply disagreed with statements made by figures like Kamala Harris, Michelle Obama, and Rep.

Who is affected

Stephen A. Smith (ESPN commentator receiving the criticism)
The National Association of Black Journalists (NABJ) and its President Errin Haines
Black women public figures mentioned: U.S. Rep. Jasmine Crockett, former VP Kamala Harris, Michelle Obama, and former MSNBC host Joy-Ann Reid
Black athletes previously criticized by Smith: Kyrie Irving, Kevin Durant, Terrell Owens, LeBron James, and Kwame Brown
FCC Chairman Brendan Carr, CBS News, The Washington Post, and Circle City Broadcasting President DuJuan McCoy (other Thumbs Down Award recipients)
Fox News host Sean Hannity
Comedian D.L. Hughley

What action is being taken

NABJ is publicly defending its decision to give Smith the Thumbs Down Award
Stephen A. Smith is appearing on media platforms (Fox News's "Hannity" show and other outlets) to reject NABJ's accusations
NABJ President Errin Haines is speaking at awards ceremonies and making public statements about accountability
Social media users and commentators are criticizing Smith's response and platform choices

Why it matters

This dispute highlights tensions around accountability within Black media and journalism communities, particularly regarding how prominent Black media figures discuss Black women in public discourse. The controversy raises important questions about the responsibility that comes with large platforms and whether successful Black commentators should face different standards when criticizing members of their own community versus responding to attacks from outside it. NABJ's willingness to publicly criticize one of America's most prominent Black media personalities demonstrates the organization's commitment to holding all journalists accountable, regardless of their stature or previous relationships. The debate also exposes disagreements within the Black community about appropriate venues for addressing internal conflicts, as evidenced by criticism of Smith's choice to defend himself on Fox News rather than through Black media platforms.

What's next

Smith's induction into the Broadcasting+Cable Hall of Fame is scheduled for September 29
NABJ has indicated "the door is open" and "the conversation is available" for Smith to engage with the organization
NABJ President Errin Haines stated the "opportunity to change is real" but emphasized the organization "will not be silent"

Read full article from source: The Washington Informer